Understanding the US Italy tax treaty is crucial for Americans living in the Italy and to Italians who have U.S. source income. This comprehensive guide breaks down the treaty's provisions, offering clarity on how it affects personal taxation and helps avoid double taxation.
Executive Summary
|
Introduction to the US Italian Tax Treaty
The US Italian tax treaty, originally signed in 1984, serves as an agreement between the two countries for determining the taxation of income where both nations may have the legal right to tax according to their respective laws. The treaty covers, among many topics, avoidance of double taxation, residency tie-breakers and discusses taxation of various forms of income, including business profits, dividends, interest, pensions, and capital gains. This article will focus on some of the key aspects of the treaty that hold particular significance.
Relief of Double Taxation
The Italian US treaty provides mechanisms for relief from double taxation, ensuring that income earned in one country by residents or citizens of the other is not taxed twice. Specifically, the treaty allows U.S. citizens and residents to claim a foreign tax credit for the income tax they pay to the Italy against their U.S. tax obligations. Conversely, Italy offers a credit for U.S. taxes paid on U.S. source income against it's own tax liabilities.
Example
Giacomo Rossi, a U.S. citizen living in Rome, earns an annual salary of $80,000. In Italy, he pays $25,000 in taxes for the year. Giacomo 's U.S. tax liability for this income amounts to $22,000. Thanks to the relief of relief of double taxation provision of the tax treaty, he is entitled to claim a foreign tax credit on his US taxes. Giacomo applies the $25,000 he paid in Italian taxes against his U.S. tax obligation, effectively reducing his U.S. tax liability to zero and even generating a $3,000 credit surplus, which may be carried over to subsequent tax years.
The Savings Clause
The Italy US tax treaty contains a "savings clause" which allows the U.S. to impose taxes on its citizens according to its own laws, even if this contradicts the the treaty. As a result of this clause, the majority of the benefits and reductions offered by the treaty do not apply to U.S. citizen expats.
Example
Lucia Bianchi, an Italian citizen and software developer, resides and works in Milan, Italy, for an American bio-tech company. She performs all her work duties in Italy and has no physical business presence in the U.S. Although the Italy U.S. tax treaty exempts such income from U.S. taxation on the basis that there is no permanent establishment in the U.S., the savings clause overrides this, requiring Lucia to declare and possibly pay U.S. taxes on her income. Nevertheless, Lucia can take advantage of foreign earned income exclusion or foreign tax credits for the taxes paid in Italy to avoid being taxed twice on the same income.
​Expert Tip: It's crucial for U.S. citizens to familiarize themselves with the savings clause exclusions in all tax treaties to accurately determine which tax benefits they can utilize. |
Tax Residency and the Tie-Breaker Rules
The United States and Italy each have their own criteria for determining who is a resident for tax purposes. It's possible for someone to meet the residency requirements of both countries simultaneously. To prevent the problems that dual tax residency could cause, the U.S. Italy tax treaty provides a series of tie-breaker rules. These rules help to decide which country has the primary right to tax the individual's income.
Permanent Home Test: The first consideration is whether the individual has a permanent home available to them in one of the countries. If a permanent home is available in only one country, that country is generally considered the individual's country of residence for tax purposes.
Centre of vital interests Test: If the individual has a permanent home in both countries or in neither country, the treaty looks at where the individuals center of vital interests lies, in other words, where they have a closer personal and economic interests.
Habitual Abode Test: If the individual has a center of vital interests in both countries or in neither country, the treaty looks at where the individual has a habitual abode; in other words, where they live regularly. This could be where they spend more time or where they have a regular presence.
Nationality Test: If the individual has a habitual abode in both countries or in neither, the next factor considered is nationality. If the person is a citizen of only one of the countries, that country is typically considered their country of residence for tax purposes.
Mutual Agreement Procedure: In the rare case that the individual is a citizen of both countries or of neither, and the above tests do not resolve the issue of residency, the competent authorities of the United States and Italy will determine the individual's residency through a mutual agreement, taking into account the person's facts and circumstances.
Taxation of US-Sourced Passive Income
Passive income from U.S. sources, which is not tied to a U.S. trade or business, is generally taxed at a flat rate of 30% if earned by a non-resident alien. However, the US Italian tax treaty lowers this rate or totally exempt it from US taxation for certain types of income. We've summarized some of the tax treaty rates in the table below. It's important to note that that these rates generally do not apply to U.S. citizens due to the savings clause mentioned earlier.
U.S. Italy Tax Treaty Table
​ | ​Tax Rate | Treaty Article Citation |
​Interest | 10% | 12(2) |
​Dividends - Paid by U.S. Corporations | 15% | 10(2) |
Dividends - Qualifying for Direct Dividend Rate | 5% | 10(2) |
Pensions and Alimony | 0%* | 18(1) |
Social Security | 0% | 18(1) |
*The exemption does not apply to lump-sum or severance payments.
Income Earned While Temporarily Present in the US
Generally, income earned from work performed in the US would be considered US source income and would be subject to US taxation. However, the US Italy tax treaty lists certain exemptions where such income is not subject to US taxes. It's important to note that these exceptions generally do not apply to U.S. citizens because of the savings clause mentioned earlier. We've summarized some of these exceptions in the table below:
​Income Type | ​Maximum Presence in U.S | Required Employer or Payer | Maximum Amount of Compensation | Treaty Article Citation |
​Employee | 183 days | Any foreign resident* | No limit** | 15(2) |
Contractor | No limit*** | Any contractor | No limit** | 14(1) |
​Public entertainment | 90 days | Any U.S. or foreign resident | $20,000 | 17 |
Teaching**** | 2 years | Any U.S. or foreign resident | ​No limit | 20 |
​Full-Time Students - remittances or allowances | No limit | Any foreign resident | No limit | 21 |
*The exemption does not apply if the employee's compensation is borne by a permanent establishment that the employer has in the United States. **Does not apply to fees paid to a director of a U.S. corporation.
***Exemption does not apply to the extent income is attributable to the recipient's fixed U.S. base.
****Does not apply to compensation for research work primarily for private benefit.
Totalization Agreement
The United States and Italy have a totalization agreement in place, which is designed to avoid double taxation of their income with respect to social security taxes. It establishes clear rules about which country's social security system covers the employee. As a result, employees and their employers can only be taxed by one country's social security system at a time.
State Taxes and the US Italy Tax Treaty
Numerous states within the United States impose income taxes on their residents. The adherence to the Italian U.S. tax treaty provisions varies by state—some may recognize them, while others may not.
​Expert Insight: Always check with a tax professional about how state tax laws interact with the treaty, as this can vary significantly from state to state. |
Need Help Navigating the US Italy Tax Treaty?
At CPAs for Expats, we specialize in helping US expats stay compliant with their US taxes. Our low fees and 4.9/5 rating on independent review platforms attests to our commitment to excellence and client satisfaction. Contact us today, and let our tax experts simplify your life and taxes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Italy have a tax treaty with the US?
Does Italy have a totalization agreement with the US?
Do Italian citizens pay tax on US capital gains?
Authored by Lewis Grunfeld, CPA
Lewis is a seasoned expert in international and U.S. expatriate taxation. With over 10 years of international tax experience, he specializes in applying tax treaties to benefit expats, handling complex tax scenarios and ensuring significant tax savings for his clients. Lewis's expertise in international compliance and U.S. expat tax returns has made him a trusted advisor in the expatriate community.